SARPA Whitepaper on Solar Energy Modifications
As adopted by the SARPA board on 16 January, 2012
SARPA (the Summit Avenue Residential Preservation Association) is dedicated to the preservation of the historic, residential, and urban park character of Summit Avenue. SARPA was commissioned in 1986 by Mayor George Latimer and the St. Paul City Council to preserve the residential quality of Summit Avenue for future generations.
A recent focus of SARPA has been to promote and encourage the fact that SARPA, while being an important historic resource, is also a street of unusual diversity. Many different kinds of people live along the street, from young to old, families to single residents, owners to renters. It’s also a street with myriad uses, from single family homes to multiple units, churches, synagogues, schools, reception houses, the Governor’s Mansion, a historic house museum, and several parks and open spaces. As such, SARPA is mainly concerned with the quality of life for all who live on — and who use — the street, and this concern is generally prioritized over individual situations.
With its interest in the diversity of historic resources, SARPA has been especially interested in the confluence of historic preservation and “green building,” particularly recent National Trust endeavors (please see source list at the end of this document). We support the Trust’s assertion that “the greenest building is the one that is already built” in that historic preservation is the “original” green building by retaining existing resources. We also support the combination of historic preservation and energy efficiency tax credits.
While energy conservation methods such as passive solar methods and geothermal wells are more or less invisible post-construction, private solar panels cause a different set of problems, enough so that they are specifically addressed in 2011 amendments to the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation. These amendments are as follows:
The Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation & Illustrated Guidelines on Sustainability for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings (2011)
Solar Technology
Recommended:
• Considering on-site, solar technology only after implementing all appropriate treatments to improve energy efficiency of the building, which often have greater life-cycle cost benefit than on-site renewable energy.
• Analyzing whether solar technology can be used successfully and will benefit a historic building without compromising its character or the character of the site or the surrounding historic district.
• Installing a solar device in a compatible location on the site or on a non-historic building or addition where it will have minimal impact on the historic building and its site.
• Installing a solar device on the historic building only after other locations have been investigated and determined infeasible.
• Installing a low-profile solar device on the historic building so that it is not visible or only minimally visible from the public right of way: for example, on a flat roof and set back to take advantage of a parapet or other roof feature to screen solar panels from view; or on a secondary slope of a roof, out of view from the public right of way.
• Installing a solar device on the historic building in a manner that does not damage historic roofing material or negatively impact the building’s historic character and is reversible.
• Installing solar roof panels horizontally – flat or parallel to the roof – to reduce visibility.
Not Recommended:
• Installing on-site, solar technology without first implementing all appropriate treatments to the building to improve its energy efficiency.
• Installing a solar device without first analyzing its potential benefit or whether it will negatively impact the character of the historic building or site or the surrounding historic district.
• Placing a solar device in a highly-visible location where it will negatively impact the historic building and its site.
• Installing a solar device on the historic building without first considering other locations.
• Installing a solar device in a prominent location on the building where it will negatively impact its historic character.
• Installing a solar device on the historic building in a manner that damages historic roofing material or replaces it with an incompatible material and is not reversible.
• Removing historic roof features to install solar panels.
• Altering a historic, character-defining roof slope to install solar panels.
• Installing solar devices that are not reversible.
• Placing solar roof panels vertically where they are highly visible and will negatively impact the historic character of the building.
SARPA’s policies have aligned with the Secretary’s Standards in the past, and our position on solar technology is no different. In general, and in keeping with its position of prioritizing the character of the district as a whole over individual instances, SARPA shall not support solar technology alterations that do not conform to these standards.
In general, that means that solar technology use on Summit shall be implemented only after other methods have been exhausted, and that such alterations shall be unobtrusive and reversible. SARPA encourages Summit Avenue homeowners to investigate a wide spectrum of energy conservation options to best preserve the quality and character of their home and of the street in general.
Sources:
- Historic Preservation and Green Building: A Lasting Relationship (http://www.preservationnation.org/issues/sustainability/additional-resources/HPandGreenBuildingArticle.pdf)
- Sustainable Stewardship (http://berkeleyheritage.com/speeches/richard_moe.html)
- Historic Preservation and Sustainable Architecture: Friend or Foes? (http://featuresblogs.chicagotribune.com/theskyline/2009/05/historic-preservation-and-green-architecture-friends-of-foes-.html)
Tuesday, January 17, 2012
Monday, January 9, 2012
Crashed Ice
Have you been wondering what on earth is happening at the eastern end of Summit next to the Cathedral? It's not church construction, or light rail, or Winter Carnival prep — it's the first-of-its-kind Red Bull Crashed Ice event!
Red Bull provides this description:
The extreme sport of ice cross downhill heads into a new season in 2012. The world championship battle will take place this year, as in 2010 for the first time, in both Europe and North America.
Red Bull Crashed Ice World Championship 2012 calendar:
Saint Paul (USA) –January 12-14
Valkenburg (NED) – February 2-4
Are (SWE) – February 16-18
Quebec City (CAN) – March 15-17
The combination of speedskating, boardercross and downhill skiing has only been around for 10 years but ice cross downhill has already overtaken many other established sports.
There are participants from 30 nations – 15,000 athletes packed into the pre-qualifying in Canada alone last year – and venues around the world that are bursting at the seams with spectators.
The rules are simple: four athletes line up at the start and the first across the finish line wins. Speed, agility, perserverance, toughness and courage at speeds of up to 60kph are the ingredients needed for success.
But I think we all know it will be even wilder and crazier than that!
The City of Saint Paul has a new website just for the event:
www.stpaul.gov/crashedice
Monday, December 12, 2011
Solar Panels?
The Union Park District Council has invited interested community members to their joint Parks and Rec/Land Use meeting on Tuesday, December 13 regarding a proposal by Summit Avenue homeowners to install solar panels at their home at 2279 Summit, extending on to Mississippi River Boulevard right-of-way parkland (the parkland had, until recently, been thought to be part of the Summit parcel and had been maintained by the homeowners).
There are six panels, each ten feet tall and four feet wide.
The homeowners applied for a diversion of the parkland, which the St. Paul Parks Commission denied on November 9, 2011 due to precedent and visual impact on the parkway. The homeowners are appealing, citing the history of maintaining the land and concerns that the panels, if built entirely on their property, would have to be 10-12 feet taller to maintain efficiency.
The meeting will begin at 5:30 p.m. in the lower level conference room at the Merriam Park Community Center (at 2000 St. Anthony).
SARPA just learned of the issue tonight and has not taken a board position.
There are six panels, each ten feet tall and four feet wide.
The homeowners applied for a diversion of the parkland, which the St. Paul Parks Commission denied on November 9, 2011 due to precedent and visual impact on the parkway. The homeowners are appealing, citing the history of maintaining the land and concerns that the panels, if built entirely on their property, would have to be 10-12 feet taller to maintain efficiency.
The meeting will begin at 5:30 p.m. in the lower level conference room at the Merriam Park Community Center (at 2000 St. Anthony).
SARPA just learned of the issue tonight and has not taken a board position.
Holiday Lights Contest!
Announcing - The Summit Holiday Lights Contest!
Please put your nominations for your favorite holiday lights on Summit in comments below or on our Facebook page (https://www.facebook.com/pages/Summit-Avenue-Residential-Preservation-Association-SARPA).
The sooner the better, we'll be judging just before Christmas!
Win fabulous prizes, fame, or something!
Please put your nominations for your favorite holiday lights on Summit in comments below or on our Facebook page (https://www.facebook.com/pages/Summit-Avenue-Residential-Preservation-Association-SARPA).
The sooner the better, we'll be judging just before Christmas!
Win fabulous prizes, fame, or something!
Wednesday, November 30, 2011
Holiday Greens
Monday, November 14, 2011
Member Event at the German House!
Join us for "Kaffeestube" — a traditional German breakfast for just $6! This Saturday, November 16, at 10am at the German Haus, 301 Summit. Look for the SARPA table!
Tuesday, November 8, 2011
Remembering Judy

On September 5, 2011, Ramsey Hill lost a founding mother. Judy McLaughlin, one of the great heroes of Ramsey Hill, passed on to party once again with other notable neighborhood pioneers and activists—Mike Hoffman, MaryAnn O’Brien, Pam Gru, Rick Raiter, Jim Czarniecki, Tom Segar, , and her husband, Mike and son, William.
Judy and Mike McLaughlin, with toddler, David, purchased the derelict mansion at 275 Summit Avenue for a vision and a song in the early seventies. Long active in politics on the state and federal level, the McLaughlins recognized the need for hospitality venue that could host political events, especially those with DFL ties, as well as young couples celebrating their wedding day. This was a bold move. Summit Avenue was tarnished—the old families were fleeing to suburban split-levels, the once stately homes were deteriorating into boarding houses, pleasure seeking johns were cruising the side streets in search of cheap thrills, and gun shots in the night were not uncommon as buyers argued with dealers.
Fortunately Ramsey Hill homes had good bones and young, urban pioneers (yuppies as they became known across the nation), had the chutzpah, if not the cash to recognize real value in behind the crumbling brick and flaking paint. It was a time when it was easy to meet the neighbors—everyone had to take a break from the plaster dust and toxic fumes. You didn’t have to walk far to find neighbors working at the same pace you were. Judy was a walker, for several years behind a stroller, and a talker and she knew who the real housewives of Ramsey Hill were long before there was reality TV.
Not incidentally, those strolls and informal sidewalk get-togethers also prompted the formation of the Ramsey Hill Association (RHA) -- and more formal way to promote the unparalleled qualities of owning a distinctive address. The house tour was originally conceived to encourage prospective homebuyers to consider the possibilities inherent in historic properties. The Progressive Dinner was an opportunity to meet new neighbors after a long Minnesota winter indoors and to share renovation horror stories and advice on where to find the best wood stripper, historic wallpaper, and cheap labor.
Swapping tales about the fate of neighborhood properties—which ones had enthusiastic new owners and which ones the city had slated for demolition and suburban style redevelopment probably prompted Judy’s passionate efforts to establish the Historic Hill District through the state legislative process. Was it fortuitous that Judy was an insider at the capital—Speaker Fred Norton’s Chief of Staff?
From this early start, Judy became an active force in the neighborhood, in leadership positions on the RHA Board, as well as behind the scenes. She first manned walkie-talkies as part of the two person crime watch teams patrolling the neighborhood in the early years searching out evil-doers and activity at the after-hours joints and then built on those skills by supervising the House Tour Sanitation Coordinating Committee. Judy was always ready to step up and volunteer for anything that would make her neighborhood a better place.
By the nineties, Ramsey Hill had turned around and the painted ladies on the streets were now homes—not working girls. Former yuppies would exclaim that there was no way they could afford to buy a home in Ramsey Hill today—it had been completely transformed into one of the premier residential locations in the Twin Cities. BUT, there was still just one more eyesore that needed attention—that awful patch of dirt and straw at the top of Ramsey Hill. Judy vowed that she’d see that piece of city-owned property renewed if it was the last thing she’d ever do.
Despite numerous capital improvement proposals, STAR grant requests, golf tournaments (the upscale equivalent of bake sales) and just about anything else to generate interest in park improvements, it was to no avail. There never was a plan that RHA, the U Club, neighbors and the city could agree on and “those people” thought that Ramsey Hill was wealthy and didn’t warrant public help, and besides, it was good enough for the croquet squad!
About the turn of this new century, 100 years after the city had purchased and sat on the property, the Ramsey Hill Association agreed to assume leadership for renovating the park in a manner worthy of placement of the historic St. Gaudens New York Life Eagle.
Judy was involved in all aspects of the transformation—from design detail to construction management to assuring that the inscriptions on the hundreds of pavers were spelled correctly. Ultimately, though, it was Judy’s long and wide range of political friendships and her well-honed persuasion skills that brought the cash to complete the job on the project that never seems to end. With her passing, one last brick will be added to the paver carpet.
In recent weeks, too many people to mention have shared Judy stories. The constant theme has been, “She encouraged me to get involved!” And she did. Whether participation in neighborhood activities, through traditional political action, or simply by voicing thoughtful concern, Judy’s influence has been vast and truly memorable.
At the Oakland Cemetery graveside service, Mayor Chris Coleman, state it best when he noted that Judy McLaughlin was taking her rightful place among the City’s movers and shakers—Alexander Ramsey, Henry Sibley, Amherst Wilder and Harriet Bishop. There was little in Saint Paul’s recent history that wasn’t touched by Judy’s hand. We’ll miss her!
(guest posy by Denise Beigbeder)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

